Cookie and the Monsters by Lucy G. – 2026 Youth Scary Story Special Commendation

Hey, it’s your host, Miss Amy Rae! While I run the Youth Scary Story Contest, I don’t judge it; since I see the names of all the participants, it’s not fair to let me loose on the entries.  But we got so many entries this year that I wanted to highlight my faves from each…
View More about Cookie and the Monsters by Lucy G. – 2026 Youth Scary Story Special Commendation

Waffles the Super Dog and the Clown by Alice B. – 2026 Youth Scary Story Contest Winner

We’re proud to announce that the 2026 winner of the Youth Scary Story Contest for 3rd through 5th grade is Alice B., a fourth-grader at All Saints Catholic School.  One judge said, “I love that the dog is the hero in the story,” finding it a creative approach to the contest prompt.  Another judge pointed…
View More about Waffles the Super Dog and the Clown by Alice B. – 2026 Youth Scary Story Contest Winner

The Girl in the Mirror by Ivy L. – 2026 Youth Scary Story Contest Winner

We’re proud to announce that the 2026 winner of the Youth Scary Story Contest for 8th through 12th grade is Ivy L., an eighth-grader at All Saints Catholic School.  “This story has the most disturbing images of all the submissions I read,” said one judge, calling the story “good, spooky stuff.”  Another said that “the…
View More about The Girl in the Mirror by Ivy L. – 2026 Youth Scary Story Contest Winner

The Showdown of the Scariness by Levi R. – 2026 Youth Scary Story Special Commendation

Hey, it’s your host, Miss Amy Rae! While I run the Youth Scary Story Contest, I don’t judge it; since I see the names of all the participants, it’s not fair to let me loose on the entries.  But we got so many entries this year that I wanted to highlight my faves from each…
View More about The Showdown of the Scariness by Levi R. – 2026 Youth Scary Story Special Commendation

The Monster in the Mirror by Squirrel – 2026 Youth Scary Story Contest Winner

We’re proud to announce that the 2026 winner of the Youth Scary Story Contest for PreK through 2nd grade is Squirrel, a kindergartner at Kenosha School of Language.  Our judges were unanimous in their decision this year, praising the story’s pulse-pounding action, descriptive language, and creative plot.  “I like the scary gory parts!” declared one…
View More about The Monster in the Mirror by Squirrel – 2026 Youth Scary Story Contest Winner

Butterflies and Mirrors by Ricky V. – 2026 Youth Scary Story Contest Winner

We’re proud to announce that the 2026 winner of the Youth Scary Story Contest for 6th through 7th grade is Ricky V., a seventh-grader at All Saints Catholic School.  Judges were generous with their praise for Ricky’s “beautifully written” prose and slow-build horror: “While on the surface this doesn’t seem like a scary story, the…
View More about Butterflies and Mirrors by Ricky V. – 2026 Youth Scary Story Contest Winner
1 - 10 of 45