The Monster in the Mirror by Squirrel – 2026 Youth Scary Story Contest Winner

We’re proud to announce that the 2026 winner of the Youth Scary Story Contest for PreK through 2nd grade is Squirrel, a kindergartner at Kenosha School of Language.  Our judges were unanimous in their decision this year, praising the story’s pulse-pounding action, descriptive language, and creative plot.  “I like the scary gory parts!” declared one judge, while another stated, “I was genuinely horrified that we started the story with four children, but ended with three!” Congratulations, Squirrel!

Want to read more scary stories?  Head back to our Youth Scary Story Contest landing page and find the rest!

The Monster in the Mirror by Squirrel

Mike, Kinlee, Kaylee, and Gerald were going to their grandma's house and they were exploring the basement. They saw an old rusty mirror. They wanted to play with it but then when they showed themselves there, a monster looked like it was creeping up behind them. Then BOOM CRASH and "caw caw" said the crow. There was a group of monsters sneaking up behind them. Then when they turned around they disappeared. Then when they looked at grandma. Grandma was being taken away by the monsters. The four kids followed the monsters. They were bringing grandma to an old rusty well. Gerald said "we should go down the well with them." Kaylee said "oh are you sure it might be dangerous. I mean, we're only 6." "Well you're right, but I want to bring grandma back!" said Gerald. Kinlee said "Ok, we should go!" Then they jumped down the well. When they were jumping down they saw dripping blood. It took five minutes for them to go down the well. Once three minutes passed by, they saw scary monster faces on the brick wall. Then finally they landed. 

BOOM! Kinlee saw blood dripping out of Gerald's head. Kinlee said "are you ok?!" Gerald said "What do you mean? I'm fine." "But there's blood dripping down your head! Now your face and hands are turning green" said Kinlee. In a puff of smoke he turned into a full monster. Kinlee, Mike, and Kaylee ran away from their only brother. They heard grandma's voice while they were running through the cave. Then the monsters started coming back for them. Then the monsters used hand cuffs to grab the three kids to stop them from using their hands. Kinlee had a stick and then she yelled “rat on the loose!” and bent down and grabbed the stick in her mouth. Once the monster turned back around, Kinlee took the stick and swung it by the monster's feet. The monster jumped up and tripped back “BOING!” onto a bouncy ball and fell into the lake and sunk to the bottom. 

The kids ran off. They heard grandma’s voice echo and then as they ran further, they heard grandma's voice louder and louder. Kinlee said “don’t worry grandma, we can free you wherever you are! We just need to find out where you are first.” Grandma shouted “OK! I’ll give you a landmark. I’m buried in a grave that has a skeleton cross!” Kinlee said “we will give you a landmark! We are by a dead crow and a lot of gems.” Grandma said “keep going straight! Once you see the statue rock, turn right!” Then they ran and ran and turned right. The three kids saw the grave with the skeleton cross. The kids said “we see it!” Then SPLASH, the monster came up from the water. The monster trips and falls. Then the kids dug grandma out and lived happily ever after.