Hey, it’s your host, Miss Amy Rae! While I run the Youth Scary Story Contest, I don’t judge it; since I see the names of all the participants, it’s not fair to let me loose on the entries. But we got so many entries this year that I wanted to highlight my faves from each age group.
Walker W., a seventh-grader at All Saints Catholic School, tells us a tale that blends together Ray Bradbury’s classic short story “The Scythe” with Stephen King’s ability to write about the ways tragedy can haunt multiple generations of a family. I loved the way the story suggests a larger world of reapers, even as our narrator only gets a small glimpse of it. Congratulations, Walker!
Want to read more scary stories? Head back to our Youth Scary Story Contest landing page and find the rest!
Family Reaper by Walker W.
I begged my mom to let my friend Jackson and me explore Grandpa’s old house. She resisted at first, but she made us promise not to go to his old study. Our grandpa was a farmer, and one day he disappeared. No one knows where he went or if he’s still alive. He’s probably not. We headed over to his house. No one has been there in 34 years. As we arrive, the sun is about to set; fog covers the field where corn once was. As we enter, the scent of mold fills the air. We run upstairs and can’t wait to discover what’s up there.
“Can we please look at his study? There might be an old coin or something cool like that,” Jackson says.
“Ok, let’s do it fast. I want to look in the old music room,” I reply.
We walk upstairs and enter his study. A burst of bright light hits me in the eyes as I turn the cold metal handle of the door.
“Wow,” we both say.
There is a huge window in the back of the room. But the room looked otherwise abandoned. No books on the bookshelf, there’s no desk. Just a huge mirror in the left corner. As we walk over to it, we realize it’s not a normal mirror; it has a scythe engraved in the wood. And at the bottom, a handprint engraved in the wood. I put my hand in just out of curiosity, and I froze. My hand fits perfectly. Then all of a sudden, the room seems to fade. Then the room goes black. I see a dark figure approaching.
“Oliver!” The figure yells.
A thought runs through my mind. How does he know my name? As he gets closer, I realize he looks a lot like my grandpa. I never got to meet him, but my mom would show me black-and-white pictures. He is wearing a black cloak and has all-white skin. “Grandpa,” I say. Then, out of nowhere, he starts crying.
“Why, why?” he yells.
“Why what?” I say.
“Your mother promised not to bring you here.” He says.
“Where are we?” I say.
He doesn’t respond.
“Thirty five years ago, I was in my study. I was studying how to make crops grow faster. I somehow created a portal to this world. All that was here was the mirror. I brought the mirror into my study and just like you, I put my hand in the handprint. Instantly, a scythe appeared in front of me and a message. The message said that I had to trap 1 person in this world.”
Then it all made sense. He had hidden all of his work so that no one would ever have the same outcome as him. He hands me the scythe and a note that reads:
All you have to do is tap someone with your scythe.
I stutter as he says, “Good luck.”
I realize that instead of trapping someone in here, he found a way to trap himself. Instantly, I get teleported back to the old study. I see Jackson’s face. I wonder why he looks so scared. Then I realize that I can’t move my arms or legs, but somehow I am walking and now running after Jackson. I pass a mirror and look in it. All I see is a black cloak, white skin, and a scythe in my hand. I try to take control of my possessed body. With all my might, I stop myself right before I am about to trap him. I then get teleported to the black dimension, and then I hear a voie.
“How did you resist it?” the voice says.
“I couldn’t hurt him,” I say.
“You’re free. You won’t have to hurt anyone. Now go home.”

Add a comment to: Family Reaper by Walker W. – 2026 Youth Scary Story Special Commendation