This was a banner year for scary stories at KPL! Despite technical issues (thanks, PHP crisis!), we received 285 stories from KPL patrons, and they were amazing. Choosing winners was a tough task, but our team of expert judges proved up to the task.
Here are our four winners for 2026:
- “The Monster in the Mirror” by Squirrel (PreK - 2)
- “Waffles the Super Dog and the Clown” by Alice B. (3 - 5)
- “Butterflies and Mirrors” by Ricky V. (6 - 7)
- “The Girl in the Mirror” by Ivy L. (8 - 12)
And because we received SO many entries this year, we’d also like to offer special commendation for the following stories:
- “The Showdown of the Scariness” by Levi R. (PreK - 2)
- Cookie and the Monsters by Lucy G. (3 - 5)
- “Family Reaper” by Walker W. (6 - 7)
- “The Empty Closet” by Kyra S. (8 - 12)
(NOTE: Kyra, an eighth-grader at Lance Middle School, asked that we not share her story online, so we aren't doing so. Trust us that it was a creepy, urban legend-ish tale full of unsettling little details!)
A note to all our other competitors: This year was a tough competition - these eight stories represent just 2.8% of the total stories we received! And I can tell you, as the person who runs the Youth Scary Story Contest each year, that we received dozens of absolutely fantastic stories - far more than just 2.8% of them. Trust me that your story was almost certainly amazing, too.
Please keep writing, keep reading, and keep trying to scare the pants off people with the ideas you make up. After all, next October, there’ll be a brand new chance to terrify your local library staff, and we’re dying to read what you come up with!

Add a comment to: 2026 Youth Scary Story Contest Winners!