Butterflies and Mirrors by Ricky V. – 2026 Youth Scary Story Contest Winner

We’re proud to announce that the 2026 winner of the Youth Scary Story Contest for 6th through 7th grade is Ricky V., a seventh-grader at All Saints Catholic School.  Judges were generous with their praise for Ricky’s “beautifully written” prose and slow-build horror: “While on the surface this doesn’t seem like a scary story, the ending really brings it all together. You suddenly connect the dots and want to reread it with your new perspective!”

Want to read more scary stories?  Head back to our Youth Scary Story Contest landing page and find the rest!

Butterflies and Mirrors by Ricky V.

Butterflies are signs of freedom. But that freedom can be taken away, either by someone or something…

Sadie walked home from school, thinking about how beautiful the weather was: grey skies, orange trees, anything eerie, just the weather she liked. When she turned a corner and started past the park, she noticed something glinting at the edge of her vision. She marched forward, deciding to take a look. It was nestled under some cheap wood chips, and she was in awe; her jaw dropped; it was beautiful. When she held it, something inside her chest opened, opened like a butterfly erupting from its chrysalis. In her hand, she held a handheld mirror. Ornate, silver, and antique. It had frosty purple butterflies, like an heirloom passed down from an aristocratic family. She glanced around to see if anyone was watching, then walked home with the mirror in her hand, studying it the whole walk back.

❦

By the time she got home, the sun was setting and painting the sky in shades of orange and pink, casting long shadows across the porch, just the weather she liked. She fumbled through her keys finding the house one. Once she grasped it and got inside, she set down her stuff and started trekking the winding staircase to her room.

“What’s that?” Her mom inquired. Sadie rolled her eyes, walked back down the stairs, and reluctantly handed the mirror to her mother.

“My, what is this?” She said, tracing her finger along the frame and handle.

“It’s exquisite!”

“I found it in the park covered with some wood chips.” She boasted.

“Okay, well, take good care of it, hon’.”

“I will, Mom!” She replied, bounding up the stairs, proud of her find.

“Very pretty,” her mother muttered under her breath.

The next night, Sadie was getting ready for Halloween.  She really thought she wasn’t going to go trick-or-treating, but something quite unusual happened.  The butterflies.  They came to life.

They were like little fairies; they helped her get ready in the most beautiful costume she had ever seen!  Ironically, it was a gorgeous butterfly costume. The costume was what a ballerina would wear at an enchanted forest recital. The whole thing was made out of her lace and silk bed curtains, which were pastel shades of green, pink, and purple. And the wings, gosh, the wings, were works of art. It looked like she stepped right out of a fairy tale.

Once the clock struck, she went out to brave the cold Halloween night. Carrying her pillowcase for loads of candy, she set out for the night. When she stepped outside, a shiver went down her spine. She looked up at the sky, a full moon.  Perfect! Thought Sadie, just the weather she liked. When she started down the street, she felt something in her chest, the same feeling when she first picked up the mirror, like a butterfly breaking free of its chrysalis.  She heard a pop!

Suddenly, she was on the road covered by something.  A thick blanket of some sort, in this case, a Halloween costume. She was a butterfly!  She flew out of the lace and into the night sky. After all, butterflies are a sign of freedom. As she was doing loop-de-loops, she noticed something following her.  A big black bird. She fluttered as fast as her delicate wings could flutter, flying for her life.  However, the butterfly was no match for the giant crow, who devoured Sadie. In. One. Bite.