Hey, it’s your host, Miss Amy Rae! While I run the Youth Scary Story Contest, I don’t judge it; since I see the names of all the participants, it’s not fair to let me loose on the entries. But we got so many entries this year that I wanted to highlight my faves from each age group.
Levi R., a PreK student at LakeView Technology Academy, brings us a tale that reminds me of Alvin Schwartz’s “In a Dark, Dark Room” - it’s full of spooky setting details that highlight just how scary this showdown is going to be. And, of course, my colleagues and I absolutely loved the story’s ending. Turns out monsters are harder to defeat than you might expect. Congratulations, Levi!
Want to read more scary stories? Head back to our Youth Scary Story Contest landing page and find the rest!
The Showdown of the Scariness by Levi R.
Once upon a time there was a mirror. And that mirror had a knot on it. And that knot was a button. And that mirror was a secret room. If you went inside it then the mirror would open and you could go inside. And then a panther would come out and come out of that room. The panther would go back out. And then there would be a flash. That flash was coming from nowhere. The flash was coming from underground. That flash was a pipe breaking in pieces. Then there was an old tiny tower. That tower had no things on it. The only thing on it was another button. That button had a secret chimney if you go inside. Then if you go inside you fall in a chimney that leads to the sewer so you can try to fix your pipes. But the flash will come again later tonight.
So there was no way that the school that no one found but someone found it that was already in it. And that person in it was named Clanty. And Clanty was 100 years old plus 1,051. And Sally was a grown up. But both their friends one year house that was a robot that a three monster and those monsters were sneaking up on a ladder but that ladder had 1,021 giant guardians of the pumpkin monsters. And those pumpkin monsters were the leader of them. And they were guarding the enter but those guys just pushed them out of the way and said nananana you can’t go here. And then there was some way that those monsters could somehow get defeated but to defeat them you have to feed them and they don’t like that so they just spit out their food. The end.

Add a comment to: The Showdown of the Scariness by Levi R. – 2026 Youth Scary Story Special Commendation