We’re proud to announce that the 2026 winner of the Youth Scary Story Contest for 8th through 12th grade is Ivy L., an eighth-grader at All Saints Catholic School. “This story has the most disturbing images of all the submissions I read,” said one judge, calling the story “good, spooky stuff.” Another said that “the creepy smiles got me good!” and praised Ivy’s unsettling take on the world of modeling. Congratulations, Ivy!
Want to read more scary stories? Head back to our Youth Scary Story Contest landing page and find the rest!
The Girl in the Mirror by Ivy L.
I stand, staring into my mirror as shadows flickered in the corners of my eyes. My phone buzzed. It was Amelia Jones, my best friend, the only person who understood the darkness around me. We were supposed to go to a modeling audition, but something felt wrong.
I grabbed my things and rushed outside before my stepmother could yell at me. The drive was silent. When we arrived, the building towered over us, its dark windows staring like a thousand unblinking eyes.
Inside, a woman in a white suit greeted us with a smile that seemed too wide. She led us into a room full of models who all looked almost exactly alike. Their faces were pale, and their eyes seemed empty. As I passed one girl, she grabbed my wrist and whispered, “You shouldn’t be here.” I spun around, but she was smiling at the wall.
When I got home, my stepmother, and stepsisters glared at me.
“WHERE HAVE YOU BEEN, CATERINA?” she screamed.
“At a modeling audition,” I whispered.
“You’ll never make it,” my stepsisters laughed. “You’re too ugly!”
I ran to my room, fighting back tears. The next morning, I received an email at school saying I had gotten in. That Sunday, I went to the agency, and they dressed me in clothes and took pictures. The cameras flashed so brightly that I could barely see. I kept seeing dark figures behind me. Every time I turned around, nothing was there. For a second, I thought I saw someone standing behind the photographer. Before I left, the woman smiled and said, “We’ll be watching you.”
That night, I stared at myself in the mirror. Then I noticed something strange. My reflection was still smiling even after I stopped. My phone rang. It was Cole, the most popular guy in school. “Can I come over?” he asked.
Twenty minutes later, someone knocked. I opened the door, and Cole was holding a small mirror. Before I could speak, I felt a cold hand on my shoulder. My stepmother and stepsisters stood behind me, wearing twisted smiles. Their eyes were sewn shut. I turned toward Cole. His eyes were sewn shut, too. Then my reflection began pounding on the inside of the mirror. CRACK! The glass shattered. Everyone grabbed me as the room spun into black and white. I heard whispering all around me before everything went dark. I woke up in bed to the smell of bacon. Just a bad dream, I thought. But my mirror was still shattered. I walked into the kitchen. My stepmother and stepsisters were making pancakes, laughing like nothing had happened. Then they slowly turned toward me. Their faces twisted into those same horrible smiles. “Hello, Cat,” they whispered.
Every piece of glass in the house shattered at once. I covered my ears as the screams began. Then came the laughter. I looked down at the broken glass on the floor. In one tiny piece, I saw my reflection.
It was smiling.
I wasn’t.

Add a comment to: The Girl in the Mirror by Ivy L. – 2026 Youth Scary Story Contest Winner