Cookie and the Monsters by Lucy G. – 2026 Youth Scary Story Special Commendation

Hey, it’s your host, Miss Amy Rae! While I run the Youth Scary Story Contest, I don’t judge it; since I see the names of all the participants, it’s not fair to let me loose on the entries.  But we got so many entries this year that I wanted to highlight my faves from each age group.

Lucy G., a homeschooled third-grader, won my heart as soon as she titled this story “Cookie and the Monsters” - I love wordplay!  Our titular heroine, an axolotl called Cookie, encounters monsters, ghosts, and classic horror settings as she explores a mirror universe; I really enjoyed the descriptions of the creepy creatures, as well as the way the tension of the chase continues throughout the story. Congratulations, Lucy!

Want to read more scary stories?  Head back to our Youth Scary Story Contest landing page and find the rest!

Cookie and the Monsters by Lucy G.

A long, long time ago there was a purple axolotl named Cookie. Cookie was very smart and loved strawberries. One day, while at home, Cookie was looking for her strawberries in her basement when she noticed a mirror. She walked towards it and it sucked her in. She closed her eyes. When she opened her eyes, she was somewhere outside and saw a monster standing in front of her. The monster was red and it had one eyeball on each of its four heads. It was the size of an adult human. She was very scared. Her body was shaking.

“Ahhhhhhh,” Cookie screamed and ran away as fast as she could.

The monster started chasing after her.  The monster chased her until she got to a house. She ran inside the house. In the house Cookie saw another monster. It was hairy and was orange and had three eyes and was dancing to some music. When the monster saw Cookie, he started chasing her. Cookie ran out of the house and now she has two monsters chasing her. She ran until she got to a graveyard. In the graveyard she saw about a thousand zombies. Cokie knew the monsters were still chasing her and she had zombies in front of her. So she quickly decided to go around the graveyard.

She ran and ran until she came to another house. She was exhausted. Cookie thought there may be somewhere for her to rest in the house. She didn’t have enough time to knock so she just opened the door. She went to the living room. She heard a loud “booing” noise.

“Who is there?” Cookie asked.

“Booooooooo!” something said.

Suddenly Cookie thought there might be a ghost in this house.  She certainly didn’t feel like running from another creature. She soon realized the only way to escape was to find another mirror. There must be a mirror in the house, she thought.

“Boooooooo!” said a possible ghost.

Cookie ran upstairs to see if there was a bathroom with a mirror in it. She opened one of the doors and there she saw a bathroom. In the bathroom, there was a mirror.

“Boom! Bang!” 

The monsters had caught up with her and were now in the house.

Cookie had to act fast.  She ran towards it and the mirror sucked her back into her basement.

“That was close!” Cookie sighed. She lived happily ever after. The end.